Critiquing Quantitative, Qualitative, Or Mixed Methods

Critiquing Quantitative, Qualitative, or Mixed Methods Studies Paper Quantitative and qualitative research studies are both significant in nursing. In this paper, I will be critiquing two articles using both approaches. Using Walden’s database system, the articles will be located and compared to one another. After this assignment, I hope to gain a better understanding if critiquing research articles. Providing care for patients diagnosed with brain tumors is the topic I selected to research. Working on a Neuro unit, I come in contact with patients that is admitted with brain tumors routinely. The first article that I selected is called Symptoms, Coping, and Quality of Life in Pediatric Brain Tumor Survivors: A Qualitative†¦show more content†¦The limitation listed caused for those children to be excluded from the study. Some children had verbal disabilities as well. The strengths were that the researchers had an audit trial and had independent auditing of the qualita tive analysis. Credibility of the article was confirmed through, the design and research questions being consistent with the interpretive descriptive methodology. â€Å"The other nurse researcher conducted member checking with three participants by presenting and reviewing a summary of the findings to verify the accuracy of interpretation. Quantitative and qualitative findings were triangulated in this inquiry, optimizing representative credibility and enhancing substantive completeness† (Macartney et al., 2014, P.392). The conclusions drawn by the researcher are the survivors experience multiple symptoms and have many way of coping with the symptoms. Their symptoms has a negative impact on their daily lives. This research contributes to nursing because through understanding the children symptoms and ways that brain tumors affect their lives we can provide additional support to the patient and families. This article gives us as nursing additional information to turn to when providing care for patients with brain tumors. Yes. There are grounds for further research on brain tumors. The second article that I selected is called Stress and burnout syndrome in hospital nurses: a descriptive study.Show MoreRelatedMixed Methods Critique1252 Words   |  6 PagesThe use of mixed methods is currently increasing in social science research since it emphasizes methodological pluralism, and provides a broader and more credible understanding of the research problem than the use of a single method (Tashakkori and Teddlie 2010). However, mixing methods for no good reason other than the sake of it can produce disjointed and unfocussed research, and can severely test the capabilities of researchers. I raise some cautionary issues in this paper by critiquing the methodologyRead MoreNurses Perceptions Of Acute Care Placements1709 Words   |  7 Pagesreview: The objective of the review is to improve acute care experiences for student nurses and improve their future practice as a qualified nurse. As well as to identify any research gaps. 2. Methodology: Through the course of this chapter the method used to obtain the literature and the exclusion and inclusion criteria shall be discussed. An account of the selection process for the final papers will be given and it will indicate the critical appraisal tools to be used and the rationale for choosingRead MoreEssay on Reconciliation between Science and Religion865 Words   |  4 Pagesstart with a question. The next step after knowing the research question is to plan how to conduct the research to answer the question. Bryman (2012) explained that scientists have to form a suitable question that can be applied in quantitative as well as qualitative research. He also indicated research questions as guidance in literature search, data collection, data analysis, and discussion. In other words, research questions keep scientists emphasize their studies, so they do not go off in unnecessaryRead MoreElements Of Creating A Search Strategy829 Words   |  4 Pagesresearch reports as the knowle dge component of effective nursing practice and includes a title, abstract, introduction, theoretical framework, a specified research question, discussion, methods of data collection, analysis, results, conclusion and references. Whether the research method is qualitative or quantitative, the table of research elements have been completed for five relevant research articles that address individuals with multiple sclerosis and their modifiable lifestyle factors. FurthermoreRead MoreResearch Article Critique2605 Words   |  11 Pagesrelationships and their impact on nursing students’ belongingness and learning’ is clear accurate and concise. Parahoo (2006) refers to the title as having little importance on the reliability of the findings. The reader should spend little time critiquing the title, abstract or literature review. It is however, the methodology of the study that determines the quality of research and most attention should be focused on this. Abstract An abstract are defined as being an overview of a study allowsRead MoreCritical Appraisal Of A Research3370 Words   |  14 Pagesappropriate and useful approach as this method provides the researcher with a greater understanding of the topic and allows the researcher to gain clarity in defining the nature of the research problem (Manerika Manerika , 2014, p.95). It also helps Byrne define a problem statement for her future research. However, the nature of this approach is associated with significant limitations, which in Byrnes paper, were coupled with problems in the research title and method that affected the believability andRead MoreEvaluation Of The Intervention Program Essay1579 Words   |  7 Pagescaregivers. A total of 407 family caregiver-patient dyad was randomized into CARE and attention categories. The CARE group was subjected to the test parameters whereas the attention group received unspecified information (Li et al., 2012). This was the method employed as per the abstract. The results yielded non-significant statistical variations on patient or family caregiver and called for an additional investigation on CARE workings and its effectiveness. The stated question seems unambiguous, it isRead MoreCritique on the Nursing Article Critical care patients’ experience of the helmet continuous positive airway pressure2101 Words   |  9 Pagespublished in the Journal of Nursing in Critical Care (JNCC). It will examine both the strengths and limitations of the study by weighing various elements of the research undertaken and its value and implication for nursing practice. It will use a critiquing tool by (Ryan, 2007) (see Appendix 1). Evidence based practice (EBP) is to offer the best care possible to individual patients and use professional judgement to determine nursing care in order to improve patient outcome and even save lives (MouleRead MoreEvaluation Of A Telephone Based Peer Support Intervention For Maternal Depression1436 Words   |  6 Pagestheir practice. The purpose of this paper is to critically appraise a research article titled, Quasi-Experimental Evaluation of a Telephone-based Peer Support Intervention for Maternal Depression by Letourneau, N., et al. (2014) by evaluating and critiquing sections of the study. The objective of this paper is to determine if the study provided valid and reliable information that can be used to implement into nursing practice. Research Problem The research problem the researchers are purposingRead MoreLiterature Review On Childhood Trauma Essay1113 Words   |  5 Pagesdisorder (PTSD) and depression, along with physical health issues and functionality with activities of daily living in older adulthood (Maschi et. al., 2013, p. 59). By understanding these effects, we can have an idea of how it occurred and what methods we can utilize for treatment options. Findings Findings of this review did show that direct exposure to traumatic experiences had higher risk of adverse effects to mental health than indirect exposure such as being a witness to violence (Maschi